
Cindy and Rich both drew muzzleloader tags for a mule deer hunt in California. They hunted hard and on day five Cindy killed this 27 inch wide 4×4 buck. That is a buck that would make any hunter proud.
Cindy writes about her buck:
We spotted my buck about 9:00 in the morning, feeding about 3/4 of
a mile away. We figured out my stalking route, and I spent about two and a half hours getting into position. After getting close to the buck (and I’m
talking bow range), I sat and waited about an hour for him to stand up.
When he finally did, he stood and looked straight at me. I panicked,
and MISSED the shot. I was devastated.
But luckily, Rich had watched where the buck ran off to, so after getting myself together, I made another stalk to the buck’s new hiding spot. This time the buck wasn’t going to stand up though. By 5:30 that evening, I knew he was going to wait until dark to come out from his hiding place. So, at that point, I decided to sneak and peak and try to get him up. But he wasn’t exactly where we had seen him bed down earlier.
He must have moved when we weren’t watching. So for about 20 minutes, I still hunted through that sage, but that wily old buck was holding like a pheasant. Finally, Ihad to admit defeat. He must have moved out of that draw and we didn’tsee him. Before heading back to the truck though, I decided to really rattle that buck if he was still around, so I let out a few loud yells.
A doe and fawn jumped up, but no buck. So, I started heading back to
pick up my pack and boots (I had shed both earlier for a quieter
stalk). Suddenly, I saw that sneaky old buck back-dooring me down the
canyon. I knew he was going to go low and cross the draw and then head
up the other side. I ran as fast as I could (in my socks) to intercept
him. I knew my only hope was that I could catch him crossing the bottom
of the draw; after that he’d be too far.
The small ridge I was on came
to a drop off, and that’s where I found a clear piece of dirt to plunk
myself down on and get my rifle up on my knees. The buck was already
crossing the draw at a trot. I didn’t range him, but I knew it would be
a relatively long shot for a muzzle loader (and for me!). And, the buck
was moving. This was throwing out a prayer, for sure! I didn’t have
time to think about it much, or get any kind of buck fever, thank
goodness. I just aimed the gun at the trotting buck, and knew I had to
time it right. I followed the buck with the gun; bounce, bounce,
bounce, BOOM! And then I heard the tell-tale thump! I had hit him.
He
ran up the other side of the draw about 40 yards and stopped. Then his
front legs wobbled and down he went! It was probably one of the most
amazing shots of my life. The bullet had entered right behind the last
rib and exited through the opposing shoulder. Needless to say, we are
still on Cloud Nine!

We spotted Rich’s buck about 12:00 noon, bedded in a bowl up on a
mountain in some sage brush. Unfortunately, the buck was bedded in such
a way that it was hard to approach him without being busted. However,
Rich got in as close as he could, on hands and knees. He got to within
176 yards, but couldn’t get any farther. Rich waited in that spot for
about an hour, and then the buck got up to feed. Rich felt that he
could make the shot with his muzzle loader, so when the buck turned
broadside, Rich leveled his open sights on the buck and squeezed off the
trigger. After the smoke cleared, Rich watched the buck run up the hill
about 30 yards and just stand there. Moments later, the buck collapsed
and rolled down the hillside. Rich had made a perfect double-lung
shot. We were both ecstatic to have one of our tags filled.